Tonight, as I tucked H in for bed, she started crying.We were lying together in her bed talking about the day when all of a sudden she pressed her face against my arm and started to weep.
“Hey, what’s this?” I asked, thinking I knew the answer. W and I had planned to fly the girls down to see their grandparents, my in-laws, while he and I went to Louisiana for the weekend. My mother-in-law had promised to take the them shopping—a late Christmas present if you will—and while C couldn’t care less about getting new clothes, H was really looking forward to the trip. But yesterday, my mother-in-law called to say she needed to change the plan. Her sister was in the hospital in critical condition and she needed to fly out to be with her. So instead of the girls spending the weekend shopping with their grandmother, my sister-in-law who lives across the bridge, is going to take care of them here. I could understand H’s disappointment. She hasn’t seen her grandmother in a while and the two are very close.
“But look,” I said. “At least you’ll won’t have to leave the puppies. And now you can go to E’s house on Saturday like you wanted.”
For a moment I felt proud of myself for pointing out this silver lining. We gave the girls puppies for Christmas and both H and C were disappointed when I told them they couldn’t take the dogs to their grandparents’. Earlier this afternoon, H had mentioned that her friend had invited her over on Saturday night. Now that they weren’t going away, she could see her friend and stay with her puppy. All things considered, it wouldn’t be a bad weekend afterall.
But when I laid all of this to her, H pressed her face against my arm, mumbling something I couldn’t understand.
“What’s that? What did you say? I can’t understand what you’re saying.” I pried her chin from the crook of my elbow and forced her to look up at me.
“I don’t want to sound bratty or anything, but I really wanted see Nani and Poppy.”
“I know. But Nani has to be with her sister.” I reminded her that this was no different than last summer when my parent’s couldn’t take the girls to Disney World because my father had to have surgery. “People get sick and they need their family’s help. You’ll have plenty of chances to go shopping with Nani. Believe me, Abercrombie & Fitch isn’t going anywhere. They’ll always have cute tops for sale.”
H nodded, but she didn’t look any happier. “It’s not just that.”
“What is it then?”
“I don’t want you to think I’m obsessing or anything.” H said, wiping her face on her bed sheet.
“I won’t think you’re obsessing. Just tell me.”
“It’s Z.”
“Z?” I had to think for a moment. “Oh . . . Z.”
H nodded. “I don’t want to be here on Saturday when everyone’s driving by. Part of the reason I wanted to go visit Nani was because I was looking forward to being away.”
I know there are a lot of books on the market about parenting. Volumes have been written about what to expect from pregnancy, labor and delivery. There are books that tell you how to trick your toddler into eating healthy foods, and others that explain how girls’ brains are different from boys’. At this point, there are so many parenting books on the market, it’s almost a joke. But I wish there was a book, just one, that warned you about the emotional rollercoaster that is parenting; one that offered surefire tips and strategies to help moms and dads hold steady when their children’s hearts are breaking. I’m not too big on parenting books. I’ve only bought one or two. But allow me to be perfectly candid here: Tonight, if I’d know of a book that would’ve told me what to say to ease H’s suffering, I’d have run right out and bought it. I’d have happily paid any price.
So here’s the story behind the story. You can stop reading now, if you’ve heard it.
As it turns out, seventh grade is prime time Bat and Bar Mitzvah season, and there seems to be two ways of doing things. This first option is to invite a small group of kids –all girls, all boys, or some small sampling of the two. Option two is to invite the whole grade. My kids go to a school that stresses inclusion– inclusion, compassion and fairness—and I’m pleased to report that most families do a decent job of abiding by this code. I know there are birthday parties my girls aren’t invited to and until now they’ve survived just fine. Of the three kids in H’s grade who’ve had Bat and Bar Mitzvah’s so far this year, all three have played by the rules. Two opted for door number two and invited the whole class and the other invited just the girls.
But one girl, Z, has chosen to do things differently and this is where I have trouble. Rather than invite all the kids or a small handful of close friends, she’s inviting two thirds of the seventh grade class. That’s right, two thirds. I don’t know what factored into her calculation or how she arrived at that number. But I don’t think you’ll have to work very hard to guess who’s not on the list. That’s right, you guessed it. You win the prize.
The good news is that none of the girls in H’s cluster of friends made the cut. Well, that’s not entirely true. Two of the girls are also Jewish, so they got invitations to the ball.
I first heard about all this in the last few days of October. H came home from school one day saying that most of the seventh grade was atwitter because their invitations had just arrived in the mail, and that Z the Bat Mitzvah girl had been overheard bragging at recess about how she’d purposely left people out.
I have to confess I was surprised and saddened by this news. Z’s mother and I aren’t close friends, but we’re certainly friendly enough, and on a couple of occasions this fall, she called to ask if I could help her out of a pinch and I’d always said yes. Similarly, H and Z aren’t close pals, but they’re not arch enemies either. So I was surprised and yes, disappointed to learn H hadn’t been invited. And here’s when I really could have used that parenting book.
Standing at the kitchen counter that afternoon, I could see from the anguished expression on H’s face, that she was wounded by the news. Wounded, though not devastated—but at some point it’s all the same. I immediately went into parenting mode, my heart racing all the while. I tried to think of all the things my mother had told me when I was H’s age, stories about girls who peaked in seventh or either grade then fall into the bottomless pit of anonymity somewhere in their high school career. Stories about Queen Bee’s who flamed out in their junior year and don’t even graduate. When I was a girl, my mother had a whole arsenal of cautionary tales to share.
And the funny thing was, most of them accurately predicted the fates of the girls I most feared, despised or admired. Marcy H, that girl who wore Candies and ass-gripping Chemin de Fer jeans on the first day of sixth grade? Burned out and pregnant by the end of her freshman year. Angie D, the girl who shoplifted Loves Baby Soft perfume and cherry flavored lip gloss from the neighborhood Five and Dime? Rehab and juvy by the time she could vote for President. And what about Molly S, Julie T, and that whole gang of wild girls who stole Vodka from their parent’s liquor cabinets and watched porn movies at high school “slumber parties?” Snorting coke and God knows what else in the bathroom at our twentieth class reunion.
I’m really not trying to be a goody-two shoes here, despite how self-righteous I sound here. I’m just saying that now that I’m a parent, I can understand everything my mother must have felt when I came home with those stories of wonder, dread or despair. I can imagine how her pulse must have raced, how her head must have spun, how mightily she surely struggled to keep breathing as she listened to my tales of woe. Now that I’m a mother, I know that churning anxiety and blinding fury, the wild impulse to throw something that must have seized her, and her struggle for self control. Because standing there making dinner, listening to my daughter tell me how tough that day had been, I felt all of those emotions and then some. I wanted to rip Z’s mother’s face off for letting her kid hurt mine. I wanted to call her on the phone or drive by her house and shout a big “FUCK YOU AND YOUR LITTLE DAUGHTER TOO!” Right then, I drew a big black line through Z’s family’s name and started plotting my revenge. If only I’d had a book or a DVD to prepare me for that moment; some visual aid or survival kit to help me brace myself against the emotional Tsumani that was headed my way.
Once again, I won’t bore you with the details, but suffice it to say, our family had a lot of conversations over the next few days about how we would have made a different choice. We talked about what it means to be a real friend, about being thoughtful but not a doormat. We talked about the futility of chasing the crowd or selling yourself for an invitation. Both W and I shared childhood war stories and even flashed some of our battle scars. And after about a week (well, maybe two) H had pretty much stopped talking about Z altogether. She assured me that she was over it. Now that she knew Z for who she really was, she’d treat her accordingly and move on. Hearing H talk, I felt confident and relieved the worst was behind us. I gave myself a parenting gold star and allowed myself to relax just a little.
So it was like a bucket of water in the face, a dagger through the heart, when it all came rushing back tonight. I didn’t know what to say. I was plumb out of stories and totally caught off guard.
And then something peculiar happened. I suddenly realized the only thing I could do was talk straight to H and see where the pieces fell. The mail man hadn’t delivered that parenting book when I needed it, and the time for stories and cautionary tales was over. If it was going to be, it was going to be me.
“Hey listen,” I said. “I know this sucks for you. It really truly sucks. It’s painful and it’s difficult, and you have a right to feel everything you’re feeling. And the thing is, it’s killing me too. I hate it that I can’t help you through this. I hate that Z wasn’t thoughtful enough to invite you to her Bat Mitzvah and that her mother didn’t have enough sense to encourage her to do the right thing. I hate that you’re in pain about this and I can’t do anything but stand by and let you work your way through it. You’re my daughter, I love you to death, and if there was a way for me to take the hit, I’d take it. But there’s not. This is the ugly, stinky downside of growing up, the flip side of Abercrombie & Fitch. But the other thing is, you really are doing a great job. It’s a hard lesson to learn but you’re almost through to the other side of this one. Saturday will come and go, and then it’ll be over. Sunday will be here before you know it and you’ll be delighted to discover you survived. I’m sorry H. I’m really, really sorry.”
Then I leaned back against the pillow and waited for H to say something. I braced myself for her to say, “Thanks, mom, but that little pep talk of your isn’t helping.” I readied my arms to hug her if she started crying all over again. But she didn’t. Much to my surprise, the straight talk actually seemed to help. I heard H sigh—a long, deep, drawn out sigh like she was finally letting go of all the demons–then she wiped her eyes and sat up.
“Can you get me a tissue?”
“You want me to get up now?” I was all toasty and warm in her bed. I didn’t want to move.
H sniffed and nodded.
Just then, I thought about delivering a brief lecture on the virtues of self reliance, but then it occurred to me that H had been pretty self-reliant already.
“Sure,” I said, throwing back the comforter.
The hallway lights were off and I had to feel my way to the bathroom. The tile floor was cold beneath my feet and I longed to be back in H’s bed. I handed her the tissue and stood over her as she blew her nose, then hugged her and planted a big fat kiss on her lips.
“I love you, sweet pea.”
“I love you too.”
“You’re going to be okay. You know that, right?”
“I know.”
“So get some sleep. It’s late.”
“Tell Daddy I said good night.”
“And no reading. Well, maybe a couple pages. Six thirty will be here before you now it.”